Competition Committee co-chairman Rich McKay does not expect there to be a lot of rules changes heading into the 2026 season, but his group is discussing many aspects of the game this week as they prepare for any proposed tweaks to the current rulebook.
One area that has come up in meetings are the rules that govern what is or isn't a catch. That part of the game came back into focus during the divisional round of the playoffs when a long pass to Bills wide receiver Brandin Cooks was ruled an interception after the ball moved from Cooks' hands to Broncos safety Ja'Quan McMillian as the wideout hit the ground. Officials ruled that Cooks did not fulfill the rules for possessing the ball before McMillian took it away, which was disputed by former Bills head coach Sean McDermott and others after the Broncos went on to win the game.
It also appeared to be a different ruling than officials came up with on similar plays at other points during the season and McKay said on Sunday that the committee "had a long discussion" related to the catch rules. He also said that the way plays look when subjected to replay has to be part of any conversation about how the rules are written moving forward.
“I think the issue on catch/no catch is that our technology today is just extraordinary," McKay said, via longtime NFL reporter Mark Maske. "And so the ability to go frame by frame and slow things down is . . . a great solution for a lot of things, but it does present challenges for others. And you need to make sure that your rules as written don’t just match up [with] what’s on the field, but how it’s looked at in replay.”
The lack of a full replay review or full explanation of the ultimate ruling on the field during the Bills-Broncos game didn't help create confidence that the ruling was the correct one. It's unclear if a change to how the rules are written would have avoided the ensuing controversy, but the lack of other proposals could lead the committee to devote more time to devising language that would avoid the same kind of conjecture about future plays.